Did the Disciples Like Matthew

The question of whether the disciples liked Matthew, also known as Levi, is a fascinating one that delves into the dynamics of early Christian relationships and the nature of acceptance within the inner circle of Jesus. As one of the twelve apostles, Matthew’s role and background have sparked discussions among theologians and believers alike. Understanding the context of his call, his background as a tax collector, and his interactions with the other disciples offers insight into how he was perceived and whether he was truly liked by those who followed Jesus. In this blog post, we will explore these aspects in detail to shed light on this intriguing question.

Did the Disciples Like Matthew

The question of whether the disciples liked Matthew is complex and layered. It involves examining biblical texts, cultural contexts, and the social dynamics of the time. To fully understand this, we need to look into Matthew’s background, his calling by Jesus, and how he integrated into the community of disciples. The available biblical accounts provide clues about their attitudes and interactions, which can help us infer whether Matthew was genuinely liked or if he faced suspicion and prejudice due to his occupation as a tax collector.


Matthew’s Background and Social Context

Matthew, also known as Levi, was a tax collector before he became one of Jesus’ disciples. Tax collectors in Jewish society during the first century were often viewed with suspicion and disdain because they worked for the Roman oppressors and were sometimes considered corrupt or dishonest. This background set Matthew apart from other disciples who were fishermen or common folk. His profession placed him at odds with the Jewish community’s values and social expectations.

  • Tax collectors were often seen as traitors for collaborating with Roman authorities.
  • They were considered sinners and outcasts by the Jewish community.
  • Many tax collectors accumulated wealth through extortion and unfair practices.

Given this context, Matthew’s calling by Jesus was remarkable, as Jesus sought out individuals marginalized by society. This background also raises questions about whether the other disciples initially accepted Matthew or if there was skepticism.


Jesus’ Call to Matthew and Its Implications

The pivotal moment that defines Matthew’s story is Jesus’ call to him in Matthew 9:9, where Jesus invites Matthew to follow Him. Unlike the other disciples, who were fishermen, Matthew’s occupation as a tax collector made his inclusion in the group extraordinary. This act demonstrated Jesus’ mission to reach out to sinners and outcasts, emphasizing the themes of acceptance and forgiveness.

When Jesus called Matthew, he responded immediately, leaving his tax booth behind. This swift response indicated Matthew’s willingness to follow Jesus despite societal disapproval. His decision to host a banquet for Jesus, which included other tax collectors and sinners, further highlights his desire to associate with those marginalized by society.

However, this decision also caused controversy among the Pharisees and some of the disciples, who questioned Jesus’ association with sinners (Matthew 9:10-13). The account shows that Matthew was not only accepted by Jesus but also actively involved in ministry and community-building efforts, which suggests that the disciples eventually grew to accept him as well.


Interactions Between Matthew and the Other Disciples

While the Bible does not provide explicit details about the personal feelings of each disciple towards Matthew, contextual clues and biblical narratives offer some insights:

  • Initial Reactions: The other disciples, especially Simon Peter and James and John, were likely cautious or skeptical initially, given Matthew’s background as a tax collector.
  • Shared Experiences: As they traveled and ministered together, their bonds strengthened through shared mission, prayer, and the challenges they faced.
  • Acceptance and Integration: Over time, Matthew’s role as an apostle and his active participation in Jesus’ ministry suggest that he was accepted as a full member of the group.

Moreover, Matthew’s authorship of one of the Gospels indicates that he was committed and valued within the early Christian community. His contributions to the narrative of Jesus’ life and teachings imply respect and acknowledgment from others.


Possible Challenges and Prejudices

Despite the eventual acceptance, it is plausible that Matthew faced prejudices from some disciples and followers due to his past. Societal attitudes towards tax collectors were deeply ingrained, and overcoming such biases would have required patience and transformation.

  • Some disciples may have harbored reservations or distrust initially.
  • Jesus’ inclusive actions challenged societal norms, fostering unity despite differences.
  • Matthew’s genuine repentance and dedication likely helped dispel any lingering doubts.

In the broader context, the story of Matthew underscores the importance of forgiveness, acceptance, and the transformative power of faith, which can change societal perceptions and personal relationships.


Reflections and Relevant Bible Verses

Several Bible verses highlight the themes of acceptance, transformation, and love that relate to Matthew’s story:

  • Matthew 9:9: "As Jesus went on from there, he saw a man named Matthew sitting at the tax collector’s booth. 'Follow me,' he told him, and Matthew got up and followed him."
  • Luke 5:27-28: "After this, Jesus went out and saw a tax collector named Levi sitting at his tax booth. 'Follow me,' Jesus said to him, and Levi got up, left everything and followed him."
  • Mark 2:14: "As he walked along, he saw Levi son of Alphaeus sitting at the tax collector’s booth. 'Follow me,' Jesus said to him, and Levi got up and followed him."
  • Matthew 9:10-13: The story of Jesus dining with sinners, including Matthew, and the Pharisees’ criticism, emphasizing Jesus’ mission to seek the lost.

These verses reinforce the idea that Jesus’ approach was inclusive and compassionate, valuing individuals regardless of their past, which also influences how the disciples perceived Matthew.


Conclusion

In summary, while there is no explicit record of the disciples expressing personal feelings about Matthew in detail, the biblical narrative suggests that they grew to accept and respect him as a vital part of Jesus’ ministry. His background as a tax collector initially might have caused some suspicion or prejudice, but Jesus’ intentional outreach and Matthew’s own response demonstrated that acceptance was possible, even for those society deemed outcasts.

Matthew’s story is a powerful reminder that genuine faith and transformation can lead to acceptance and unity within a community. The disciples, guided by Jesus’ example, learned to look beyond societal biases and embrace individuals for who they truly are in God’s eyes. Ultimately, the story encourages believers today to embody the same spirit of love, acceptance, and forgiveness that characterized Jesus’ ministry and Matthew’s journey from sinner to saint.

Back to blog

Leave a comment